How to Solve Tricky Math Questions Without Guessing - QuestX Quiz featured image

How to Solve Tricky Math Questions Without Guessing

Tuesday, 27 October 2026
11 min read

Every student who has tried to solve tricky math questions under a ticking clock knows the feeling. You read a maths question, read it again, and nothing happens in your head. The clock's ticking away. The answer options are just sitting there, and one of them sort of looks right, so it's very tempting to click it and move on.

Now, sometimes a guess really is the smart move, like with ten seconds left on a paper that doesn't punish wrong answers. But most of the time a tricky question will give way if you poke it the right way. The kids who do brilliantly in competitions, in our experience, aren't lucky guessers at all. They've just got a handful of go-to moves for when their brain goes blank. Below are the ones we teach, with examples you can try at home (they're quite fun to spring on grown-ups over dinner, too).

Why gut-feeling guesses usually go wrong

Question setters are a sneaky lot. They write the wrong options on purpose to match the mistakes kids usually make, so if you go with your gut, you're quite likely to walk straight into the trap they built for you.

Go and try this one on whoever's on the sofa right now. It comes from a famous 2005 thinking test by psychologist Shane Frederick, and plenty of university students get it wrong. A bat and a ball together come to $1.10, and the bat's a dollar dearer than the ball, so what did the ball cost?

"Ten cents," says almost everybody, instantly.

"Okay. So the bat's a dollar more than that..."

"A dollar ten. Oh. That makes a dollar twenty altogether. Hang on."

It's five cents, with the bat at $1.05. Not a hard question at all, really. It just shows that the first answer your brain coughs up isn't always the one to trust, and that's why it's worth having a method, and the practical tips to get better at math offer more.

Move 1: read it like a detective

So many "hard" questions are only hard because somebody read them at a sprint. We get kids to go through with a pencil, underlining the bits that matter and drawing a ring round any sneaky little word, like "not", or "remaining", or "at least". Oh, and units, because a question that mixes centimetres and metres is basically a mark-stealing machine.

After that, we make them explain the question back to us like we're a bit slow. "Right, so it's not that the bat costs a dollar... it costs a dollar MORE." The moment they can say that out loud, they've usually cracked half of it.

Move 2: split "know" from "need"

Lots of questions feel scary because everything's knotted together in one long sentence. Untangle it on scrap paper with two columns, one headed KNOW and one headed NEED, and drop each bit of information in the right one. Weirdly, once it's sorted like that, the next step often just sort of waves at you.

Move 3: draw something, anything

If we could only teach one move it might be this one. A scrappy drawing turns a wall of words into something your eyes can actually work with.

And it isn't just for shape questions. For fractions and "how much more" questions we love a bar model. Minus numbers and timelines get a number line. When it's about ages or who's sitting where, a little table does the job. Stick people are fine. Nobody's marking the art.

Back to the bat and ball. Draw a short bar for the ball. Draw the bat as that same bar plus an extra bit labelled "$1". Now cover up the extra dollar, and what's left is two ball-sized bars making 10 cents, so each one's 5 cents. Kids go "ohhh" at the drawing in a way they never do at the algebra.

Move 4: shrink it

Big numbers or loads of people? Shrink it to something silly and small, spot what's happening, then blow it back up again.

Our favourite is the party one. Six guests, and everybody shakes everybody's hand once, so how many handshakes in total? It nearly always plays out like this.

"Let's start with two people."

"One handshake."

"Three people?"

"Er... three."

"Four?"

"Six! It's going 1, 3, 6. So five people is 10 and six people is 15."

Some kids find a second way. Six people each shake five hands, that's 30, except every handshake got counted twice (you with me, me with you), so halve it, 15. When two different routes end up in the same place, you can be fairly sure you're right, which fits with mental math tricks for math competitions.

Move 5: go backwards

Some questions hand you the ending and ask how it all started. For those, we tell kids to press rewind.

"I'm thinking of a number. I double it, add 6, divide by 4, and end up with 5. What's my number?"

"Okay, so the last thing they did was divide by 4, so I'll times by 4... 20. Before that they added 6, so take it off... 14. And before that they doubled, so halve it. Seven?"

Check forwards and it works, seven doubled is fourteen, plus six is twenty, and twenty shared by four is five. It's a brilliant move for those "Sam spent half his pocket money, then £3, then..." questions, and for age puzzles too.

Move 6: list things in order

Counting questions are sneaky. You miss one, or count one twice, and there goes the mark. The cure is dull but it works, which is to make the list in a sensible order.

"How many squares can you find on a 3 by 3 grid?"

"Nine!"

"Any bigger ones hiding?"

"Oh... the 2 by 2 ones. There's... four of those. And the whole thing's a square. So fourteen?"

Exactly. Yep, fourteen. Going size by size meant nothing got lost, whereas hopping about randomly is exactly how kids land on thirteen and can't work out why.

Move 7: let the numbers do the talking

Now and then you can answer a question without doing any sums at all, as long as you know a few of the habits numbers have.

"Can five odd numbers add up to 20?"

Kids usually start trying combinations. 1 + 3 + 5 + 7... hmm. Then someone clever pipes up. "Odd plus odd is always even. So four odds make an even, and adding the fifth odd makes it odd again. And 20's even. So no, never." Spot on, and not a single sum tested.

It's worth knowing a few of these number facts really well. There are the odd and even rules, of course. Add up a number's digits and you'll know if it's in the three (or nine) times table. Last digits follow patterns. And here's a fun one: a square number can never end in 2, 3, 7 or 8.

Move 8: use the answer options

In multiple choice, the options are clues, and using them well isn't guessing at all. It's reasoning.

Here's a lovely example. Which of these is in the nine times table, 2,345 or 3,456 or 4,567 or 5,678? You could start dividing, groan. Or you could add up the digits of each one in your head. Only 3,456 gives a digit total that's a multiple of 9 (it comes to 18), so that's your answer, no division at all.

Other times, the quickest way is to try each option in the question. "A dad is three times as old as his son. In ten years he'll be twice as old. How old's the son now? Is it 5, 10, 15 or 20?" Try 10. Son's 10, dad's 30. Ten years on, son's 20 and dad's 40, and 40 is twice 20. Done in about fifteen seconds.

And if you're truly stuck, you can still bin the daft options, the ones that are miles too big or negative or odd when the answer's obviously even.

Move 9: imagine the worst luck

Whenever you see "guarantee" or "be certain" in a question, imagine you're the unluckiest person alive, because that's usually what the setter wants.

It's 6am, the power's off, and you're fumbling in a drawer of 10 red and 10 blue socks. How many do you need to pull out to be certain you've got a pair?

We've heard every answer going, eleven, twenty, two. But picture the worst luck. First sock's red, second sock's blue, grr. The third one has to match one of them, because there are only two colours. So it's 3.

"Seventeen!" says the speedy guesser, having divided 51 by 3. Close, but read it again, it asks for the biggest. Seventeen is the middle one (the middle of three evenly spaced numbers is always the average), and odd numbers hop up in twos, so the three must be fifteen, seventeen and nineteen. They add to 51, phew. Biggest is nineteen. Careful reading caught the trap, a number fact gave the shortcut, and a check made sure, all in about thirty seconds.

Move 10: does the answer make sense?

Once you've got something, give it ten seconds. Does it answer what they actually asked? Is it a sensible size? Does it fit every condition? Can you pop it back in? That little check is what catches the traps. The ten-cent ball, for instance, falls apart the moment you add it up and get $1.20.

Putting a few moves together

Real competition questions often need more than one move. Try this. Three odd numbers in a row add up to 51, so what's the biggest one?

So when IS guessing okay?

When the clock's nearly out and wrong answers don't cost anything, for sure. When you've crossed out a couple of options and it's down to two, that's an educated guess and perfectly sensible. And when you've hit your time limit on a question, though flagging it to come back to is better if you can. What you really want to avoid is a blind guess as your first move. Knock out two options and you've got a fifty-fifty. Guess blind on four and it's one in four, and on a question full of traps it's probably worse. If wrong answers lose marks, be extra choosy.

Making the moves automatic

None of this is any use if it vanishes from your head the second the clock starts. After solving any tricky problem, say which move you used ("I drew it", "I went backwards"). Keep a little card with the moves on it beside you during practice until you don't need it. Try solving problems two ways, which gives you flexibility and a free check. When you fall into a trap, write down what the trap was so you'll know it next time. And practise on competition questions, since they're stuffed with traps and twists, which makes them perfect training. For a few more tricks, have a look at our 10 problem solving techniques used by maths champions, and for the clock side of things, our time management tips for online maths competitions.

A quick word for parents, actually. When your child's stuck at the kitchen table, it's awfully tempting to just tell them which move to use. Try asking instead. "Could you draw it?" or "What if there were only two people?" lets them find the door themselves, and the look on their face when they do is worth the extra five minutes.

Get these into your bones and tricky questions start feeling less like a brick wall and more like a puzzle with a door in it somewhere. Your job's just to find the door.

If your child would like to try the toolkit on some real exam questions, Quest X is our online maths exam company, running exams for Years 3 to 10 in the UK, USA, Canada, Australia, Ireland and New Zealand. There's number, shape, data and logic in there, and plenty of the questions reward exactly this kind of careful, step-by-step thinking.

QuestX Quiz is an international online maths exam for students in Years 3 to 10. Families in the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, the USA, New Zealand and Ireland can take part in QuestX Quiz.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do first when a question looks too hard?

Read it twice, underline what is being asked, and write down what you already know. Many tricky questions become simple once the information is laid out.

Is it fine to draw diagrams?

Yes. A quick sketch or table often shows the pattern that the words hide, and it costs only a few seconds.

How can I check an answer without redoing the whole question?

Test the answer against the original wording, or estimate roughly and see if the result is sensible.

How can students practise tricky questions at home?

Pick two or three harder questions a week and talk through the method, even after finding the answer. Online exams such as QuestX Quiz give students in many countries a steady source of this type of question.